A puzzle that blurs the lines
At first glance, the riddle appears simple: some multiplication problems lined up, a logical sequence to complete. Nothing more basic than “3×3” or “4×4”. One might assume it’s basic elementary arithmetic. But soon, a detail disturbs the peace: the results don’t match. “3×3” no longer equals “9”; instead, it equals “12”. “4×4” doesn’t give “16”; it results in “20”. Here, the rules of classic arithmetic have vanished. A different logic has slipped behind the numbers.
When the usual logic becomes a trap
This is the hallmark of a good puzzle: it makes us believe we already know the answer, only to lead us astray. We rely on our multiplication reflexes, seeking a familiar result… and end up missing the mark.
The solution lies elsewhere. Here, each equation conceals a modified rule, a twisted mechanism that forces us to change our perspective.
An inspiring anecdote
Legend has it that a famous Indian mathematician, Srinivasa Ramanujan, had a knack for perplexing his peers and even his teachers with such unconventional reasoning. Where everyone saw a classic multiplication, he perceived an opportunity to transform the operation into something else, manipulating numbers like pieces of a puzzle.
One day, when a colleague asked him why he wrote a “false” equation on the board, Ramanujan simply replied:
“It’s not false; it’s just another way of looking at the truth.”
This phrase perfectly encapsulates the spirit of puzzles like this one: they do not aim to contradict mathematics but to open a new door. The logic is there, merely hidden behind a deceptive facade.
An exercise in observation above all
These puzzles do not merely test your calculation skills. They challenge your ability to slow down and observe. Because the obvious can be misleading.
In reality, each operation is a classic square… with something more added. A slight shift, invisible at first glance, but it changes everything.
Here is the answer we found:
1) Observe the given equations
3×3 = 12
4×4 = 20
5×5 = 30
2) Compare with the usual square
3×3 = 9 → here it’s 12 → difference +3
4×4 = 16 → here it’s 20 → difference +4
5×5 = 25 → here it’s 30 → difference +5
3) Formulate the rule
Each time, we add the first factor:
n × n = n² + n
(equivalent to n(n+1)).
4) Verify the rule on the examples
3² + 3 = 9 + 3 = 12
4² + 4 = 16 + 4 = 20
5² + 5 = 25 + 5 = 30
5) Apply to the question
- 8×8 = 8² + 8 = 64 + 8 = 72.
Answer: 72.
If you enjoyed this challenge, don’t forget to take on more challenges from our recommended reading section by clicking here.

