G

Judged as “too made up” at the gym, this rugby player responds to criticism

Why should one have to choose between strength and makeup? Why would mascara prevent someone from lifting weights? In response to comments about her makeup during a workout, American rugby player Ilona Maher chose to answer with flair—and a few impressive lifts.

A Question That Bothers… and Inspires

Recently, Ilona Maher shared a video on Instagram that opens with a provocative text: “Why do you wear makeup when you train?” Setting the tone, she appears in gray leggings, a high ponytail, and understated jewelry, flashing a serene smile. She quickly transitions to demonstrating bench presses with 75 pounds, crisp pull-ups, and controlled rowing—all while sporting mascara and lipstick.

Her response is both simple and impactful: “Why not? It doesn’t make me weaker!” A statement that resonates powerfully, she even underscores it in the caption of her video: “My mascara won’t thin my muscles or erase my work ethic.” In other words, her appearance does not define her performance or determination.

In 2025, as a finalist on “Dancing with the Stars,” she became the first woman to lift her male partner during the competition. Again, Ilona Maher defies stereotypes: yes, you can be powerful, muscular, and spectacular—and still enjoy wearing gloss.

The Ongoing Scrutiny of Women’s Bodies

Behind this video lies a broader reality. Women’s bodies are continuously scrutinized, commented on, and analyzed. “Too made up,” “not enough.” “Too muscular,” “too thin.” “Too visible,” “too discreet.” The principle is straightforward: you should do what you want with your body, your face, and your style.

While wearing makeup to the gym may not be highly recommended from a dermatological perspective—primarily because foundation can clog pores and hinder skin respiration during exertion—it remains a personal choice. If you prefer a natural look while sweating, that’s perfectly fine. If you feel more confident with a swipe of mascara or something else, that’s equally valid. Your strength is neither defined by your lipstick nor the lack of it.

A Wave of Support

Under Ilona Maher’s post, reactions are pouring in: “We should be free to wear makeup or not,” “Thank you for addressing this,” “With an Olympic medal and lifting those weights, makeup is the least of our concerns.” With over 5.4 million followers, Ilona Maher conveys a message that extends far beyond the rugby field. Body positivity, empowerment, and self-affirmation: she embodies a generation that refuses to choose between its many facets. Powerful and stylish. Muscular and groomed. Serious and playful: she demonstrates that performance and personal expression can coexist without contradiction.

By lifting weights as well as responding to criticism, Ilona Maher underscores a fundamental truth: your body belongs to you. And you have every right to inhabit it as you see fit.